 |
Ross William Hamilton/The Oregonian |
I wanted to write today about the National Championship game last night between Auburn and Oregon but I only saw the first half. When will the NCAA learn that starting a game after 8:30 on the East Coast, especially a national championship game, is not conducive to loyal viewership. There are many people that love college football but need to be up by 5 or 6 the next day for work or school. Now I know what your thinking, the West Coast viewers need to rush home from work to see the game start at 5:30, right? That's true but being an East Coast person, I DON'T CARE! If the NCAA cared then they would play their biggest game of the year at 6:30 on a Saturday or Sunday but we all know that would never happen because the NFL is God and the TV networks don't want competition. Ultimately I guess it really isn't the NCAA's fault, it's TV's fault.
Anyway, while I'm on this rant I might as well finish what I started and tell you everything that's wrong with NCAA Football. First we have the bowls. There are way too many of them and they drag out way too long. The National Championship game this year was played on January 10th. That is 37 days since both teams last played a game. That's right, 37 DAYS! Typically the season ends on the first weekend in December but some season end Thanksgiving weekend. That will still leave almost a month layoff with the traditional bowl games being played on January 1st. I personally believe that the long layoff doesn't produce the best football. Just look at last nights game that featured two of the most proficient offenses, a Heisman Trophy winner and a finalist. The play was somewhat sloppy at times (from what I got to see) and the scoring was low with the outcome being 22-19.
Now that the bowls are finally over we can look back at 35 bowl games. 35 bowl games, seriously? That's 70 of the 120 FBS schools or 58.3%. Of these eligible schools, we had 16 teams that finished 6-6, 1 that was 7-6 and 16 teams that finished 7-5. That's almost half that had a mediocre record. Weren't bowl games at one time a reward for having a good season? Nine years ago there were 25 bowl games. 20 years ago there were only 19 bowl games. The bowl season is too washed down now. There was a time that I cared about the games but anymore they are just an afterthought.
Many have debated about ending the bowl games completely and moving toward a playoff system. I don't think this is completely needed but I do think changes need to be made and there can be a compromise using both systems. Many have proposed using the bowls as part of the playoff but I think travel would be too much and the bowls tradition would be lessened. Right now we have the Orange Bowl, Rose Bowl, Sugar Bowl, and the Fiesta Bowl as the major BCS Bowls with a couple like the Cotton Bowl and Capital One Bowl as lesser majors. These can all be utilized. First I propose there is a playoff. No matter what, the NCAA needs a playoff and I believe that if they are going to have conferences then all conference champions need to be included.
Right now there are 11 conferences. I propose that 5 at-large's be included to bring the number to a total of 16. Seedings and the 5 at-large's will be determined by the BCS standings. The top 5 in the BCS get seeded right along with the conference champions. The first weekend of the playoffs will be the first weekend after the conference championship games and the top 8 seeds will have a home game. The following week will be the quarterfinals and these games will be played the 3rd weekend of December. That will then leave 4 teams remaining and these games will also be played at the higher seeds on the 4th weekend in December. The Championship will be played two weekends later in January at one of the four BCS locations on a rotating basis. The other three BCS bowls will be played on January 1 and these bowls will be able to choose 6 of the 12 eliminated playoff teams. Other bowls will be cut down in number, will choose from non-playoff teams and must be played on January 1 or before. Based on my proposal, the first weekend would have played out in the following way:
(16) Troy vs. (1) Auburn
(9) Michigan St. vs. (8) Arkansas
(13) UCF vs. (4) Stanford
(12) Virginia Tech vs. (5) Wisconsin
(14) Connecticut vs. (3) TCU
(11) LSU vs. (6) Ohio St.
(15) Miami, OH vs. (2) Oregon
(10) Boise St. vs. (7) Oklahoma
This year the first round would have been on December 11, Quarters on December 18 and the Semis would have been pushed off until December 31 or January 1 and I would have left the championship game the weekend of January 8th. It wouldn't be perfect but it would be a start and would also be much more exciting than the way its set up now plus the best team would win the championship!